Remove this ad

avatar

Pandem0nium

Posts: 11,981 The Butterfly Effect!

#2801 [url]

Jun 9 10 3:01 PM

DEAD @ christina's numbers.

I knew her MTV movie awards performance SUCKED.

Witness the FULL POWER of the LAMB-FORCE !!!
SheepCircle.jpg picture by emancipati0n 
(¯`·ÞåndémÖn!ûM·´¯)

Remove this ad
avatar

carlos b fly

Administrator

Posts: 22,071 You'll never be ready. Memba I told you!

#2802 [url]

Jun 9 10 3:02 PM

jasp17 wrote:
Colson wrote:
carlos b fly wrote:
esettle0 wrote:
59 is not a 'good' score.


I know. How is 59 good? That dosent put it anywhere in the green for Metacritic. 





60 is a green score on metacritic. Beyonce's last one 'only' had a 62.
Well, that wasn't a very good album either, so you still don't have a point.

a score from 70 onwards is GOOD to me, 60 is mediocre.



  


Regardless of Jasps own preferences, he is right - a 59 on Metacritic is nothing to rave about at all. Thats far from 'good'.

avatar

Colson

Posts: 18,927 FOMM Extraordinaire

#2803 [url]

Jun 9 10 3:06 PM

It's all relative. TEOM didn't get a 'good' score neither. So I guess it isn't a good album.

#2804 [url]

Jun 9 10 3:08 PM

Colson wrote:
It's all relative. TEOM didn't get a 'good' score neither. So I guess it isn't a good album.

Succes does not equal a critically acclaimed album!!!




avatar

carlos b fly

Administrator

Posts: 22,071 You'll never be ready. Memba I told you!

#2805 [url]

Jun 9 10 3:20 PM

Colson wrote:
It's all relative. TEOM didn't get a 'good' score neither. So I guess it isn't a good album.


Thats major backtracking though - you said the score on Metacritic was good. It isnt. Its not even scrapping 60 at present. TEOM and Bionic could both be two of the greatest albums of all time but the point is, neither fared well on Meta.

Trashing Mariahs own album is low and not even what we're discussing.
  

#2806 [url]

Jun 9 10 3:22 PM

carlos b fly wrote:
Colson wrote:
It's all relative. TEOM didn't get a 'good' score neither. So I guess it isn't a good album.


Thats major backtracking though - you said the score on Metacritic was good. It isnt. Its not even scrapping 60 at present. TEOM and Bionic could both be two of the greatest albums of all time but the point is, neither fared well on Meta.

Trashing Mariahs own album is low and not even what we're discussing.
  
Amen!
I love how all the people I dislike on this forum burn they're own fingers today




avatar

rainbow1199

Posts: 12,520 Often imitated, never duplicated.

#2807 [url]

Jun 9 10 3:40 PM

kevo2002 wrote:
^I bet those Xtincta stans were having a field day when Memoirs underperformed, all being like "wait til the KWEEN shows her how it's done"
LMAO.  I think her fans have been inhaling too much of the peroxide she puts in her hair.

I would also like to inform you that thanks to your post a few days ago, I cannot listen to that 'Glam' song without hearing 'clown' in my head .  Thanks a lot.  Not that it's a particularly great one- can't believe the producer had the balls to compare it to 'Vogue'.

image

avatar

mcfan

Posts: 31,640

#Beautiful

#2808 [url]

Jun 9 10 3:40 PM

Colson wrote:
It's all relative. TEOM didn't get a 'good' score neither. So I guess it isn't a good album.
Sorry, but I didn't get this one. So TEOM is now comparable to Bionic based on its Metacritic score?

Critics have never been kind to Mariah when it comes to reviewing her albums and you know it. Just like I'm sure you know TEOM sh*ts all over Xtina's mess.


  

 

avatar

esettle0

Posts: 21,128 Reflections of your love have come to wither

#2810 [url]

Jun 9 10 4:03 PM

Colson wrote:
It's all relative. TEOM didn't get a 'good' score neither. So I guess it isn't a good album.
No, its not relative, its very simple. 60 and up is good, 59 and down bad. you are clearly being bias and calling 59 good because you like her.

  

Remove this ad
avatar

Kevon

Administrator

Posts: 37,640 'Showing receipts and offering seats'

#2811 [url]

Jun 9 10 4:06 PM

rainbow1199 wrote:
kevo2002 wrote:
^I bet those Xtincta stans were having a field day when Memoirs underperformed, all being like "wait til the KWEEN shows her how it's done"
LMAO.  I think her fans have been inhaling too much of the peroxide she puts in her hair.

I would also like to inform you that thanks to your post a few days ago, I cannot listen to that 'Glam' song without hearing 'clown' in my head .  Thanks a lot.  Not that it's a particularly great one- can't believe the producer had the balls to compare it to 'Vogue'.

LMAO I know, once you are alerted to that "subliminal message" you can't really hear anything else, can you 



Wrapped up in a shady tortilla

avatar

mariahfan150

Posts: 33,673

You're going to miss my love in the middle of the night...

#2812 [url]

Jun 9 10 4:10 PM

esettle0 wrote:
Colson wrote:
It's all relative. TEOM didn't get a 'good' score neither. So I guess it isn't a good album.
No, its not relative, its very simple. 60 and up is good, 59 and down bad. you are clearly being bias and calling 59 good because you like her.

  
Yeah, it's in the 'green' category. Back To Basics scored 69 by comparison, so this album isn't as well received as that at least.



seattlesfinest's Profile Page

avatar

Colson

Posts: 18,927 FOMM Extraordinaire

#2813 [url]

Jun 9 10 4:23 PM

carlos b fly wrote:
Colson wrote:


It's all relative. TEOM didn't get a 'good' score neither. So I guess it isn't a good album.


Thats major backtracking though - you said the score on Metacritic was good. It isnt. Its not even scrapping 60 at present. TEOM and Bionic could both be two of the greatest albums of all time but the point is, neither fared well on Meta.

Trashing Mariahs own album is low and not even what we're discussing.
  




Learn how to 'read' and interpret. I was referring to jasp comments that I Am...Sasha Fierce isn't a 'good' album when I referred to it also having a score of 62, which isn't that far from 59. Obviously many posters on here wouldn't agree with that score and consider that a 'good' album.

How in the hell am I trashing TEOM when I was using it's 'low' score as a comparison to the score current score Bionic and IASF received. Sheesh, you all are so damn slow.

avatar

Colson

Posts: 18,927 FOMM Extraordinaire

#2815 [url]

Jun 9 10 4:24 PM

esettle0 wrote:
Colson wrote:


It's all relative. TEOM didn't get a 'good' score neither. So I guess it isn't a good album.
No, its not relative, its very simple. 60 and up is good, 59 and down bad. you are clearly being bias and calling 59 good because you like her.

  




You sound foolish. There is not that much difference between a 59 and 60. I could see if you're talking about at least a 10 point difference.

Last Edited By: Colson Jun 9 10 4:27 PM. Edited 1 time.

avatar

esettle0

Posts: 21,128 Reflections of your love have come to wither

#2817 [url]

Jun 9 10 4:31 PM

Colson wrote:
esettle0 wrote:
Colson wrote:


It's all relative. TEOM didn't get a 'good' score neither. So I guess it isn't a good album.
No, its not relative, its very simple. 60 and up is good, 59 and down bad. you are clearly being bias and calling 59 good because you like her.

  




You sound foolish. There is not that much difference between a 59 and 60. I could see if you're talking about at least a 10 point difference.

not as foolish as 59 being 'GOOD'. I could see if u said its 'not that bad', but GOOD? please.
  

avatar

Colson

Posts: 18,927 FOMM Extraordinaire

#2819 [url]

Jun 9 10 4:35 PM

esettle0 wrote:
Colson wrote:



esettle0 wrote:



Colson wrote:




It's all relative. TEOM didn't get a 'good' score neither. So I guess it isn't a good album.
No, its not relative, its very simple. 60 and up is good, 59 and down bad. you are clearly being bias and calling 59 good because you like her.

  




You sound foolish. There is not that much difference between a 59 and 60. I could see if you're talking about at least a 10 point difference.

not as foolish as 59 being 'GOOD'. I could see if u said its 'not that bad', but GOOD? please.
  




AGAIN...I said it's 'currently' a good rating based on the metacritic rating system (not my own), which if it had 60(1 point away), they consider that 'favorable' overall review. This is the last time I'm discussing this. Y'all are draining me.

avatar

esettle0

Posts: 21,128 Reflections of your love have come to wither

#2820 [url]

Jun 9 10 4:36 PM

Colson wrote:
esettle0 wrote:
Colson wrote:



esettle0 wrote:



Colson wrote:




It's all relative. TEOM didn't get a 'good' score neither. So I guess it isn't a good album.
No, its not relative, its very simple. 60 and up is good, 59 and down bad. you are clearly being bias and calling 59 good because you like her.

  




You sound foolish. There is not that much difference between a 59 and 60. I could see if you're talking about at least a 10 point difference.

not as foolish as 59 being 'GOOD'. I could see if u said its 'not that bad', but GOOD? please.
  




AGAIN...I said it's 'currently' a good rating based on the metacritic rating system (not my own), which if it had 60(1 point away), they consider that 'favorable' overall review. This is the last time I'm discussing this. Y'all are draining me.

ok
  

Remove this ad

Quick Reply

bbcode help