#1 [url]

Sep 6 07 11:51 PM

ugh this thread is sooo disgusting... can't we close it?.. i want to just throw up reading all this... whats the point of continuing to rehash redundant opinions about alicia... i swear jason, you've been repeating your little ideas for years.... its ur opinion that her songs aren't insightful... why can't you EVER just put two words at the begining of your sentences that say "I THINK"

u are so condescending critisizing Alicia's lyric writing ability on a MARIAH CAREY board. Mariah may have really great talent for phrasing, time, rythym... but her lyrics aren't any more insightful than anything Alicia's written. They write about the same things...


Alicia has TREMENDOUS insight into what its like to be in love and in a relationship.... everything about her music is from the gut and honest... so just stop the blatant and negligent hating.

ooh yeah, let me take my own advice

I THINK Alicia has TREMENDOUS insight into what its like to be in love and in a relationship.... I THINK everything about her music is from the gut and honest... so just stop the blatant and negligent hating. please? i mean seriously, just take a look around...



I brought up Beyonce cuz god forbid someone calls out that fake one... but alicia is a "snooze fest" here and unoriginal. I seriously think Mariah fans have a complex cuz Alicia is more critically well received than Mariah is --- I don't like that Mariah gets dissed by the critics, but i'm not going to say Alicia doesn't deserve it... she does.

Last Edited By: heightsgarage Sep 6 07 11:58 PM. Edited 3 times.