^Yeah, but that was just for ONE week. If she was a judge she would be on every week and would have more to say and sooner or later, you know it's going to be something 'controversial' and the rabid fans of 'certain' singers on the show are going to hate her for making certain comments about their favorites even if it's a good critique. Mariah wouldn't be a good judge if all she had to say were good things about everyone even if they give a piss poor performance.