#1 [url]

Jun 9 10 5:34 PM

Colson wrote:
carlos b fly wrote:
Colson wrote:


It's all relative. TEOM didn't get a 'good' score neither. So I guess it isn't a good album.


Thats major backtracking though - you said the score on Metacritic was good. It isnt. Its not even scrapping 60 at present. TEOM and Bionic could both be two of the greatest albums of all time but the point is, neither fared well on Meta.

Trashing Mariahs own album is low and not even what we're discussing.
  




Learn how to 'read' and interpret. I was referring to jasp comments that I Am...Sasha Fierce isn't a 'good' album when I referred to it also having a score of 62, which isn't that far from 59. Obviously many posters on here wouldn't agree with that score and consider that a 'good' album.

How in the hell am I trashing TEOM when I was using it's 'low' score as a comparison to the score current score Bionic and IASF received. Sheesh, you all are so damn slow.



Nope - you are still backtracking and deflecting what you said.

The point was, 59 points is hardly good (as you made out). I dont care about what TEOM got, you started dragging that up when people tore into you over defining 59 as good. I'm not going to start going off track debating whether Bionic or TEOM got unjust reviews. Maybe they did but thats a differant discussion. I get what you are saying about Beyonce as well but again, its a tangent to get away from your original point/statement. 

They got what score they did, they werent all that great and the scores are what they are.

Last Edited By: carlos b fly Jun 9 10 6:27 PM. Edited 2 times.