#1 [url]

Mar 27 08 1:18 PM

The Rebirth Experience wrote:
breakbreakdown wrote:
The Rebirth Experience wrote:
hunguponu wrote:
This is sooooooo obvious Madonnas song is just selling cause it cares the "feat. Justin Timberlake" ... I reember when Mariah went #1 with Thank God I Found You and everybody was like "oh she needs them to be #1" But now that Madonna is close to #1 on iTunes everybody forgets that it is cause Justin and Timbaland are selling the song. Madonna is just featuring. I like Madonna, but lets just be honest. I wanted to see how Madonna would do if 4 minutes was just a Madonna song.

In Madonna's defense, "Hung Up" was a huge download hit, and "4 Minutes" is doing better in airplay in it's second week than "Hung Up" had at it's peak.

In hunguponu's defense, you should be comparing Hung Up's downlads to 4 Minutes' downloads: I'm quite positive 4Minutes will sell more than Hung Up image, so if 4 Minutes didn't feature Justin Timberlake, we would be celebrating image

I am comparing them. I'm saying if "Hung Up" could go to #1 in downloads and hang around for months and sell hundreds of thousands of singles, I don't see how people can say the only reason Madonna is selling anything is because of Justin Timberlake other than that a lot of Mariah fans just like to make +%*$ up to make Madonna look bad.

I never said Madonna wouldnt sell, I know she is a digital seller, and Im not a Madonna hater, I really like her and I dont like to compare her to MC, but as long as it is the new trend, Im doing it as well. What Im saying is that, madonna would never be a treat if she released a song by herself. She would sell a lot, just it. Radio wouldnt be playing 4 minutes if it wasnt a Justin + Timbaland song. Like it or not. I know she will eventually go #1, Ive already said that... But the fact that radio is playing this song just gives it power to be treat for the #1 spot on Hot100... not now...but in the furutre we know it will.